What's the difference between a climbing rose and a rambling rose?

By Val Bourne

Val Bourne advises a reader who wants to plant some roses on a pergola but doesn't know the difference between a climber and rambler
Climbing rosesClimbing roses

The short answer is that rambling roses usually flower once whereas climbers usually repeat flower throughout summer and autumn, but there are exceptions.

If you want your garden to be smothered in roses during June choose a rambler as repeat-flowering climbers only give you measured flushes of flower and never make quite the same impact.  

The ideal combination is a June-flowering rambler planted close to a repeat-flowering climber. Then allow one of the gentle late-summer viticella clematis to twine through them.  This way you should have flowers until September.

Whichever you choose all roses flower better if trained because bending and coiling the stems slows down the flow of sap and promotes more flowering shoots.

The best time to train climbing roses is autumn when the shiny new stems can still be bent and turned without breaking.  Choose strong stems and, armed with thick gloves and goggles, curl them round a stake or pillar or loop them along the top of the fence.

You can also buy hooped rose trainers for shrub roses, or simply bend the branches down to the ground and fix them down ( www.helmingham.com)

Ramblers

You prune rambling roses when you train them by simply cutting out some of the old stems at the base. These are replaced by new strong branches. The branches should be fanned out from the base, rather like a fruit tree, if the rose is against a fence and then the stems can be looped along to the top edge of the fence, rather like looper caterpillars.

Did you know?

  • Ramblers are very disease tolerant as many are close to species roses.
  • Also once-only roses don't need deadheading and some will produce a crop of hips.

Five star ramblers

1. 'Goldfinch'  - shiny, coppery foliage and clusters of small apricot roses that fade to cream.

2. 'Sander's White'  - deep-green leaves and loose clusters of late white flowers,  particularly good in semi-shade.

3. 'Veilchenblau' - faded purplish flowers that are stunning against grey-tinged stone.

4. 'Paul's Himalayan Musk' - clusters of the palest pink flowers. Too vigorous for fences and better up a large apple tree.

5.  'Phyllis Bide' - a repeat-flowering rambler with small apricot-to-yellow flowers - a restrained grower perfect for a pillar

Climbers

Climbing roses are pruned in winter and they need a more sympathetic regime. Slightly reduce the main leaders and prune back the side shoots to six inches.

Most climbers are more highly-bred and therefore prone to black spot, a fungal disease of roses. The greenest way of keeping your roses clean is to either mulch under the rose bush or under plant with lavenders, violas, hardy geraniums or campanulas. Both methods will prevent the fungal spores from being washed back on to the rose.

Did you know?

  • All repeat-flowering roses need to be dead headed to encourage more flowers.
  • Climbers vary in habit enormously . Some, like 'Lady Hillingdon', hang their heads down while others can only be admired from the roof.

Five star repeat-flowering climbers

1. 'New Dawn' -silver pink flowers set against apple-green foliage - beautiful underplanted with blue catmint

2.' Aloha' - a horrible name for an excellent deep-pink pillar rose.

3. 'Madame Alfred Carrière' - a blush-white noisette rose that is unbeatable on a north wall or in shade.

4. 'Madame Gregoire Staechelin' - large-glowing pink flowers with a sweet-pea scent followed by hips.

5. 'Penny Lane' a recently bred, honey-champagne rose with a good scent

Late Summer ' Viticella' Clematis - perfect for growing through roses

The following five are drought resistant should be pruned back to the lowest buds in early spring

1. 'Etoile Violette' a dark, purple-blue clematis with widely-spaced petals - best with peach and pink roses

2. 'Purpurea Plena Elegans' a faded maroon-red pompom - good with paler roses particularly pale-pinks.

3. 'Madame Julia Correvon' single claret flowers good with pale-pinks and apricots

4. 'Betty Corning' this frilly lilac-flowered clematis has pink veins and it can be grown close to any pink rose.

5. 'Alba Luxurians' - a green-tinged white clematis - grow near or over any vibrant climbing rose

Related

  • Debutante rose by David Austin

    Rambling roses

    I want to plant some roses to cover a wooden fence - which ones shall I choose?

    Read on

  • Scented rose

    I want to plant some scented roses. What do you suggest?

    Scent is vital in any garden: it gives more sensuous pleasure than anything else and roses can provide it in variety and abundance.

    Read on

  • County of Hampshire Rose

    Rose 'County of Hampshire' (Korverlandus)

    Val Bourne introduces this gorgeous new rose

    Read on

  • Aphid

    How to tackle aphids

    Are your buds embattled by bugs? Martyn Cox tells us how to tackle the sap suckers before they destroy your plants

    Read on

  • Snail thumb

    How to control slugs and snails

    There are many pests that cause problems in the garden, but none with a more voracious appetite than slugs and snails.

    Read on

  • Val Bourne

    How to liven up a rose bed

    "My rose bed looks very dull when the roses aren&'t out. How can I improve it?" Renowned gardening writer Val Bourne has the answer

    Read on

  • Home thumbnail

    Home insurance

    Cover of up to £50,000 for contents and up to £500,000 for buildings as standard.

    MORE DETAILS

  • Holiday home thumbnail

    Holiday home insurance

    All the cover you need for your holiday home abroad.

    MORE DETAILS

  • Home phone and broadband

    Home Phone and Broadband

    MORE DETAILS


  • Constance

    Posted: Wednesday 2 May 2012

    I have a 7 foot tree runk that I wish to conceal. It's in semi~shade against a wall. Would it be suitable to train rambler/climber roses around it. Was thinking of two. If so which varieties woould be suitable?

  • Abby

    Posted: Saturday 24 March 2012

    you have that wrong. read above. She states that ramblers flower once and climbers re flower.

  • Hilary

    Posted: Friday 2 March 2012

    You say a climbing rose flowers once but ramblers repeat flower throughout the summer. Mine seemed to flower for ages, with hundreds of flowers very like the rose in your picture. It was once used as the stem for a graft to make it into a half standard, but the graft failed and it reverted back into whatever it was before. Now it is much bigger than the arch it grows on. I don't want to wait till Autumn to prune /train it if it is a climber, because then it will be huge. What should I do?

COMMENTS

Type your comment here


 characters remaining.

Saga Magazine

Claim your free issue today and find out why we're the UK's bestselling monthly magazine.

Saga Magazine e-newsletter

Sign up to our FREE weekly newsletter, delivered to your inbox every Friday.

More gardening articles

Browse our extensive archive for more gardening news and advice from our gardening experts.

Home insurance

Over 50s save up to 25% online

  • Cover for buildings insurance up to £500,000 
  • Contents insurance up to £50,000
  • Half price Saga Home Response.

Saga Dating

Sign up and create a FREE profile today

  • Set up a free profile
  • Search for people by age and area
  • Browse other member’s profiles and photos