Fruit or crisps? The FRUIT is cheaper

By Judith Wills, Friday 30 November 2012

This week the 'too poor for fruit' excuse won't wash with diet blogger Judith Wills. Plus, Judith shares her recipe for low-fat fish pie.
Judith WillsJudith Wills

A recent survey of our eating habits finds that consumption of fruit and veg has gone down in the UK compared with the last similar Government survey – the reason being that prices for these have 'rocketed' (as the tabloid headlines always have it) in the past five years.

And in the same week, another research project finds that we are filling up on 'cheap' starches such as sliced bread, pastry, biscuits and crisps to keep our food costs within budget.

I put the word 'cheap' in inverted commas because I was in one of the major supermarkets in Hereford the other day and noticed the price of crisps – a 40g 'serves one' pack of a typical brand was 66p. On the other hand, a single apple was 15p and a single banana 12p. So you could get two apples and three bananas for the same price as a bag of crisps.

A non-luxury brand of chocolate coated biscuits was £1.90. Three biscuits (an average serve, I guess) would then be 24p. So you could get two bananas instead of the biscuits, or one banana and one apple would be just 3p more.

My point? You can get fruits containing important nutrients such as vitamin C, potassium and fibre for the same price as virtually vitamin and mineral-free, high-fat/sugar/salt starches. And it's a fallacy that fruit is bound to contain fewer calories than the crisps or the biscuits.

There are around 200 calories in the 40g bag of crisps and 250 in the three biscuits. There are 340 calories in two apples and three bananas so you get 140 more calories than the crisps for the same price as well as a lot of good nutrients and no baddies. So if you are skinny and trying to get your calories then on all counts the fruit wins.

But the sad fact is that a lot of people claiming they have to 'fill up' on starchy low-nutrient foods as they can't afford fruit and veg, are actually very overweight or obese. I would lay a bet that there are fewer thin than fat people surviving on low incomes.

However, if you're strapped for cash and really do need to lose weight, eat the two apples with just one banana – 42p and 180 calories, saving 20 calories and 24p compared with the crisps. Or eat two bananas – 24p and 160 calories, saving 90 calories and spending no more than you would on the biscuits.

Case proven.

Ate last night

I craved a fish pie so I concocted a reasonably low-calorie one rather than the butter and cream laden ones that can so easily find there way onto a dinner plate. It served four, is about 475 calories a portion, and will freeze.

Judith's low-fat fish pieJudith's low-fat fish pie recipe

  • 800g mixed fish fillets – I used salmon, farmed cod and smoked haddock
  • 500ml skimmed milk
  • 100g cooked peeled prawns
  • 3 eggs, lightly hard-boiled, peeled and quartered
  • 1 tbsp sauce flour
  • 2 tbsp half fat crème fraiche
  • 4 tbsp grated Parmesan cheese
  • Handful fresh chopped parsley
  • Little salt and black pepper
  • 600g boiled potatoes mashed with skimmed milk, a dash of light olive oil and seasoning

1. Skin any fish as necessary and place fillets in a large lidded pan. Pour over the milk and simmer gently for 3 minutes. Remove fish to a plate, using slotted spatula, break into large chunks as necessary and arrange in ovenproof dish, pouring any juices left on the plate back into the milk. Scatter the prawns and egg around the fish then tuck in a little. Strain milk through sieve into a saucepan.

2. Stir sauce flour into the milk and whisk over medium heat until it thickens. Stir in the crème fraiche, half the cheese, all the parsley and seasoning to taste. Pour over fish, lifting fish pieces so the sauce gets all the way to the base of the dish.

3. Spoon the potato all around the edge of the dish in a rustic fashion. Sprinkle remaining cheese over everything and bake at 180C for 25 minutes or until golden. Serve with plenty of green vegetables.

Follow Judith's progress from the beginning in the Diet Challenge archive.

Join the discussion on Saga Zone forums

Read Judith Wills' diet forum thread and share your own diet and weight loss experiences.

The opinions expressed are those of the author and are not held by Saga unless specifically stated.

The material is for general information only and does not constitute investment, tax, legal, medical or other form of advice. You should not rely on this information to make (or refrain from making) any decisions. Always obtain independent, professional advice for your own particular situation.


  • Judith Wills

    Goodbye to the 'shiver me slim' diet

    Judith decides that sitting huddled up in an unheated house in an attempt to boost her metabolism is just not a price worth paying

    Read on

  • Judith Wills

    Joanna Lumley and me – it's over

    Judith is left gobsmacked by Joanna Lumley’s attitude towards weight loss and exercise

    Read on

  • Judith Wills

    Slim or fit? I know which I'd choose…

    Judith applauds recent research results showing that it is better to be overweight and fit than slim and unfit

    Read on

  • Judith Wills

    Chills, they're multiplying

    Judith looks on the bright side of the onset of winter and shares her recipe for slightly spicy beef shin stew

    Read on

  • Judith Wills

    I don't belieeeeeve it!

    The perplexing issue of food with virtually no calories makes Judith wonder why on earth people would pay more to eat less

    Read on

  • Judith Wills

    Something fishy going on…

    Judith's love of fish and chips leads her on a journey to find the healthiest alternative to the traditional supper. Plus, try her favourite low fat recipe for yourself

    Read on

  • Judith Wills

    Baking – why?

    Judith wonders whether the nation’s obsession with baking is really the best thing for a country struggling with an obesity epidemic

    Read on

  • Judith Wills

    Low-cost supermarkets with hidden slimming benefits

    Judith reveals that discount supermarkets like Aldi and Lidl do a lot more than just save money - they can also be good for the waistline

    Read on

  • Health Club

    Health Club

    Free membership and free online assessment to see how healthy you could be.


  • HCP thumbnail

    Health Cash Plan

    You can claim up to 75% of your common everyday healthcare expenses including dental and optical treatments.


  • Saga Health Insurance

    Health insurance

    A comprehensive range of competitively priced HealthPlans.



Type your comment here

 characters remaining.

Diet and wellbeing blog

Judith Wills has been one of the UK’s best-known experts on diet, nutrition and health for 25 years and is the author of over 30 books. However, she describes her own body as ‘the result of years of healthy lifestyle triumphs and disasters in equal measure’. Follow her progress as she gets back into shape.

Saga Magazine

For more fascinating stories and insightful articles, why not try Saga Magazine for just £1 for 3 issues.

Health Insurance

Choose Saga Health Insurance for...

  • Prompt access to private medical treatment
  • A great choice of HealthPlans
  • Easy to take out cover.

Keep up to date with the latest health news by signing up to our fortnightly health e-newsletter.