The Nigella enigma

By Judith Wills , Friday 14 September 2012

Judith has her very own theory to contribute to the discussion about the Domestic Goddess’s yo-yoing weight.
Judith WillsJudith Wills

Nigella Lawson and her weight. Now there is an endlessly fascinating topic on so many levels.

This year, is she thinner or fatter? This week, is she fatter or thinner? This TV series, this book, are we to see total voluptuousness, or toned-down/toned-up curvaceousness? Does she tell the truth about her size, or porky pies? Does she diet, does she overeat, or does everything that happens to her body just happen, on its own with no input whatsoever from the pouty one – my favourite theory?

Wow, this topic -  it's so exciting. Without it our daily papers and weekend supplements would be THIS much thinner themselves, and the online gossip sites and chatrooms would almost fall silent.

And here I am, adding a little bit this week to the great ocean of the unstoppable Nigella publicity machine. Why?

Well, I couldn't help myself. She really is an enigma. Let's look at the facts:

1.  She's been 'curvy' ever since she's being doing cookery on TV, no denying it.
2.  Last year her 'curvy' turned to lots and lots of surplus pounds, as shown in her wetsuit/burquini on the beach. Even die-hard Nigella-figure fans seemed to agree she could now officially be called 'fat'.
3.  Nigella images vanished from our papers and screens and eventually we got over the shock of (2.). 
4.  Late August, 2012 - Nigella has a new book and TV series to promote and thus she re-appears. But several of her pounds have, in the meantime, done a vanishing act. 

That much we know. Here's where it gets really, really exciting.

Nigella claimed back in April that she has lost weight due to her bunions being removed.  Surely they weren't that big?   No – apparently she couldn't make the journey to the fridge so frequently as before, so she couldn't eat so much cake.  (Funny, that, I keep my cake in the cake tin, it's not so good when it's too cold, unless it's refrigerator cake, of course.)

Then it's rumoured she's been 'doing' the very expensive top people's weight loss system, Bodyism Genesis where you pay £30,000 or more to drink water and get motivated. 

Now she says she gets fat when she makes a TV series because of the stress and she can't sleep.  She says this makes the weight come on with no change of diet.  So my theory that her body has a weight life of its own, see above, is sounding like the winner right now, but that could soon alter.

Meanwhile, can I just say something?  Could not her weight gains when she makes TV series be just a little to do with the food that she cooks – and presumably eats - while she's doing it?  Her latest offerings are her own version of Italian.  How about double cream chocolate and meringue ice cream with chocolate sauce?  Calabrian meat lasagne with hard-boiled eggs and mozzarella?  Pavlova – no fruit, just the meringue and whipped cream?  Chocolate, almond and olive oil cake?  Coffee ice cream in a large white bun?

A quick look back at her other cookbooks shows page after page of high-fat, high-cal treats.

Come on Nigella, perhaps it's time to do a Hairy Bikers and show us how to eat and pout and enjoy, without all the heart-attack-on-a-plate dishes that could, just could, have something to do with your weight problems.


The opinions expressed are those of the author and are not held by Saga unless specifically stated.

The material is for general information only and does not constitute investment, tax, legal, medical or other form of advice. You should not rely on this information to make (or refrain from making) any decisions. Always obtain independent, professional advice for your own particular situation.

Related

  • Judith Wills

    I'm missing the Hairy Bikers

    Judith celebrates the Hairy Bikers' common sense approach to dieting and shares her recipe for delicious low calorie chilli crabcakes

    Read on

  • Judith Wills

    Three weeks of sleepless nights

    Judith finds that her new diet plan is causing some very restless nights

    Read on

  • Judith Wills

    The lazy route to weight loss

    Judith finds herself feeling thoroughly foggy instead of revitalised after her fortnight’s holiday, but at least she’s not hungry

    Read on

  • Judith Wills

    SO annoying - more rubbish about 'exercise makes you fat'

    Media reports denying that exercise can help with weight loss make Judith see red

    Read on

  • Judith Wills

    I'm renaming it the National Gluttons Scheme

    A nice, healthy walk round a local open garden on a Sunday afternoon seemed a lovely idea, until disaster struck at the cake stall…Judith Wills confesses all

    Read on

  • Judith Wills

    The irony of comfort eating

    Looked at logically, comfort eating really is completely pointless – so why do we do it? asks Judith

    Read on

  • HCP thumbnail

    Health Cash Plan

    You can claim up to 75% of your common everyday healthcare expenses including dental and optical treatments.

    MORE DETAILS

  • Saga Health Insurance

    Health insurance

    A comprehensive range of competitively priced HealthPlans. 3 months free when you pay by monthly Direct Debit.

    MORE DETAILS

  • Personal accident thumbnail

    Personal Accident insurance

    A choice of two levels of cover from just £6.50 a month.

    MORE DETAILS

  • Life insurance

    Guaranteed life insurance

    No medical examinations and full payout after just one year.

    MORE INFO

  • Platinum thumbnail

    Platinum credit card

    Low rate and 0% foreign currency fees on transactions.

    MORE INFO

  • Web Savings thumbnail

    Fixed rate savings account

    For simple lump sum deposits designed for those looking for an attractive fixed rate.

    MORE INFO


  • alan hadley

    Posted: Sunday 23 September 2012

    I could not give a damm about Nigella Lawson's weight - who cares? It's her business and nobody else's in any case

  • Carl Stansfield

    Posted: Saturday 22 September 2012

    This is a nice send up. I am afraid that when she appears I switch chanels. Her simpering self promotion is so boreing & as for the food - well does she live on a different planet where food is not acceptable unless it is laden with cardiac arresting fat - Bring back Jamie Oliver, who at least has talent for producing delicious healthy meals. Sadly yet another case of only getting on T.V. due to family connections.

COMMENTS

Type your comment here


 characters remaining.

Saga Bookshop

20% off Judith Wills books

Order online or by telephone, plus enjoy FREE DELIVERY if you spend over £15.

Saga Magazine

For more fascinating stories and insightful articles, why not try Saga Magazine for just £1 for 3 issues.

Saga health e-newsletter

Keep up to date with the latest health news by signing up to our fortnightly health e-newsletter.

Partner discounts

Travel deals and exclusive savings

  • City breaks, self-catering accommodation and much more 
  • Ferries, flights and a choice of hotels 
  • Get more from your holiday with our travel extras