Car review: Honda HR-V

Carlton Boyce / 06 February 2017

Thoughtful touches and hidden delights make the HR-V an easy companion.



Score 8/10

The HR-V, Honda’s entry level SUV and the smaller brother to the CR-V, might not be the most exciting car in its class but it might just be one of the most satisfying to own. 

For a start, the interior, which is the bit you’ll be seeing the most of, feels far more upmarket than the modest purchase price might lead you to expect; the quality of the plastics is better than most with soft-feel touches throughout and plenty of hidden delights and thoughtful touches. 

It is also completely free of shakes and rattles, even over the harshest road surface, helping lend the HR-V an ambience that is rarely found in a car that costs so little.

Prefect for carrying passengers

It’s reasonably roomy too with a big boot and better rear legroom than many of its competitors, making it a good choice for anyone who regularly carries passengers in the back. 

It also features the nicest sat-nav I’ve used in a long time. I have to resort to the car’s instruction manual far too frequently, but the little Honda’s was simplicity itself to set up and use. Top marks there.

Changing gears is no grind

While we’re being positive, the gear change on the six-speed manual gearbox draws special praise. While I’m a big fan of automatic gearboxes in my everyday car, the gearchange on the HR-V is exemplary, which compensates (to a certain extent) for the lack of an auto option on the diesel-engined model. 

The gearchange itself isn’t quite as nice as either the one on my Honda NSX or the new Mazda MX-5, but it isn’t far off, which is a remarkable achievement in a marketplace in which cost cutting and good-enough features abound. 

Incidentally, you can have an automatic if you chose the petrol engine but as it’s a CVT (constantly variable transmission) I’d stick with the manual; no matter how appealing they are in theory, CVT gearboxes are rarely a good idea in practice…

Manual vs automatic

Rapid, effortless progress

Returning to the subject of the 1.6-litre diesel engine, I have to point out that it is a gruff old thing, especially at higher revs. However, it’s willing and delivers a fat wad of torque across a broad rev band; the power output might be slightly lower than the equivalent petrol engine but the oil-burner delivers almost twice as much torque. It’s torque, not outright power, that is the key to rapid, effortless progress, something the HR-V is particularly adept at.

A contributing factor to the Honda’s loping gait is the handling, which is taut and accurate and balances the needs of the keen driver with that of the passenger very well; the ride is very good and body roll is well contained. Even a very quick cross-country run in the rain failed to induce anything in my wife other than a sense of surprise at how quickly we’d arrived at our overnight stop.

The small details thought about

The little stuff is just as comprehensively engineered as the big. As an example the automatic headlights switched between high and low beam seamlessly, never once blinding other drivers.

 However, it has to be said that while the operation is flawless, the execution is more of a mixed bag. While the dipped beam was a cool, piercing white, the high beam was a much warmer yellow in colour; this might seem like a small grumble (and I do accept that it is very much a First World Problem) it was a constant irritation and smacked of penny pinching rather than engineering incompetence.

A few little niggles

While I’m moaning, the gruff engine note can be overly intrusive at times, the sat-nav threw the occasional hissy fit by directing me through narrow village streets, only to have me rejoin the main road I’d left just a few hundred yards previously and I hated the electronic handbrake that wouldn’t release unless you were wearing your seatbelt. 

I understand the need for safety but when you are hopping in and out of the car to open and then close a series of farm gates along a farm track it very quickly becomes a pain in the … neck (Speaking of which, the HR-V is only available as a front-wheel-drive, no matter what its chunky, ready-for-anything appearance may infer.)


Carlton Boyce If you enjoy Carlton's inimitable style of writing, you'll love his motoring column - to have each one delivered straight to your door every month, subscribe to Saga Magazine today!

Low maintenance

On the whole, though, I enjoyed my week with the Honda; its time with us coincided with a few childfree days that we spent walking in the mountains of mid-Wales. The HR-V served as a very competent support vehicle, swallowing muddy rucksacks and boots and wet clothing (this was Wales in August, obviously…) and a quick wipe with a damp cloth saw the leather seats looking as good as new again.  

We also appreciated the innumerable places to store your road-trip detritus including a pair of large cup-holders for your morning coffee and a handy USB port under the centre console to charge your phone after a day in the mountains has depleted its charge.

Oh, and the automatic wipers worked just as brilliantly as the headlights, which was handy given the torrential rain that marked a significant portion of the week. Just another example of how the HR-V is an easy companion, despite its (relatively few) faults.

Stats

Power – 118bhp

Torque – 221 lb ft

0-62mph – 10.5 seconds

Top speed – 119mph

Kerb weight – 1,399kgs

Official average fuel consumption – 68.9mpg

Honest John real world fuel consumption – 58.5mpg

CO2 emissions – 108g/km

VED class – Band B

Towing capacity (braked) – 1,400kgs

Towing capacity (unbraked) – 750kgs

Warranty – 3 yrs/60,000 miles

Price – £26,055

Price as tested - £26,580

Best-in-class 

The Suzuki Vitara S doesn’t feel anything like as nice as the HR-V inside but it is much nicer to drive and usefully cheaper to buy. If your priority is driving pleasure – or you need the reassurance of four-wheel-drive - then you need look no further.

The best of the rest

The Hyundai Tucson is a fine example of a thoroughly modern SUV that would be very easy to live with.

Left-field alternative

The Renault Kadjar is the best small SUV/crossover you probably haven’t ever heard of.

Defaqto 5 star car insurance 2016
PROMOTION Saga Car Insurance Great Cover, Great Price!
Defaqto 5 Star Rated Comprehensive Cover.
Over 50? Click to get a quote!

The opinions expressed are those of the author and are not held by Saga unless specifically stated.

The material is for general information only and does not constitute investment, tax, legal, medical or other form of advice. You should not rely on this information to make (or refrain from making) any decisions. Always obtain independent, professional advice for your own particular situation.