Avoid getting ripped off by a garage

Gareth Herincx / 05 February 2016

Finding a reliable garage can be difficult but our tips will help you avoid being ripped off.



For many of us, visiting a garage can be a daunting, baffling and costly experience.

Even if you think you know your way around a car, we’re all increasingly at the mercy of mechanics as vehicles become more hi-tech.

Basic car maintenance jobs you can do yourself.

Tracking down a good garage is a bit like finding a trustworthy plumber or builder, but don’t despair. Follow some of our tips and you may just land a reliable one, plus read on to avoid potential rip-offs.

How to find a good garage

What is your car trying to tell you? Our guide to common car issues and their symptoms.

Getting work done

Even when you think you’ve found a garage you can trust,  there are ways to lessen the risk of getting ripped off – whether you have a specific repair or you need to book your car in for an annual service or MoT.

Six in 10 motorists worry about hidden costs when booking their car into a garage for an MOT, service or repair, according to research carried out by RAC Garage Compare in 2015.

While an Auto Express/ Warrantywise survey, also in 2015, revealed that average hourly car labour rates vary by as much as 220% across the country. The highest were found in Twickenham, south west London, (£141); the cheapest were in Kirkwall, Orkney (£44) and the UK national average was £84.30 per hour.

Six obscure motoring laws you probably don't know.

Top tips

  • As a general rule, look for a garage that provides open and transparent pricing.

  • Do your homework. If it’s a relatively simple repair or a basic part that needs replacing, you may be even be able to do it yourself.

  • Don’t just take one garage’s word for it – get a second or third opinion.

  • Sometimes your local garage may not be the best option. Consider going to one of the big chains, such as Halfords Autocentres, Mr Clutch,  ATS Euromaster or Kwik Fit which all offer fixed-price servicing and repairs, as well as offering specific repairs.

  • You can now shop around online too, using websites such as ClickMechanic and WhoCanFixMyCar, which allow you to obtain quotes from garages and book online.

  • If you use an online service, such as one of the above, and you’re still not convinced, see if there are any reviews available on sites, including The Good Garage Scheme, Find Me A Garage and The Good Garage Guide from Honest John.

  • Once you’ve decided which garage is going to be entrusted with your car, always ask for a written quote and make sure it includes parts, VAT and, especially, labour, which can vary enormously. Be specific about the work you want the garage to carry out.

  • Check if the garage will give you a guarantee – some will provide a warranty on their work so you can go back if anything goes wrong.

  • Ask the garage to call if they find anything over and above the agreed work. If it’s expensive, you still may have the option to have the work done elsewhere.

A new breed of motorway speed cameras will show motorists no mercy. Find out more...

  • If you’re advised to get other work done, such as new brake pads or tracking (steering alignment), it may not be urgent and, as long as it’s not illegal or dangerous, you could get the work done at some stage in the future or somewhere else.

  • When you collect your car, make sure you get a receipt and keep it safe.

  • Finally, when you take your car to a garage for servicing or repair, you enter into a legally binding contract with the garage owner. The contract is controlled by many laws including the Supply of Goods and Services Act 1982, which gives you certain consumer rights.

Good luck. And if you find a trustworthy garage and you’ve had a good experience, stick with it and spread the word online and amongst your friends and family.

For more tips and useful information, browse our motoring articles.


With the highest possible rating from independent financial research company Defaqto for our comprehensive cover, Saga Car Insurance is worth considering. To find out more click here.

The opinions expressed are those of the author and are not held by Saga unless specifically stated.

The material is for general information only and does not constitute investment, tax, legal, medical or other form of advice. You should not rely on this information to make (or refrain from making) any decisions. Always obtain independent, professional advice for your own particular situation.