Economic policies are damaging spending power of people over 50

By Dr Ros Altmann , Thursday 6 September 2012

A report published by the Saga Foundation raises serious concerns about negative impacts of Bank of England monetary policy.
 What would happen to your savings if a bank collapsed?Saga is suggesting a four-point plan to kick-start growth and boost employment

The research indicates that the “toxic combination” of ultra-low interest rates, quantitative easing (QE), and overshooting inflation has slashed the spending power of 21 million older citizens, helping push the UK into recession.

This analysis challenges the conclusions of a Bank of England report last month, which claimed QE had boosted the wealth of UK households by around £600billion and led to increased spending.

The report, compiled for Saga by experts from the Centre for Economics and Business Research (CEBR), reveals that Britain's over 50s suffered a 9% drop in real incomes between Q1 2008 and Q2 2012. This led them to reduce their spending, sucking £24.7billion out of the economy, equivalent to a 1.6% fall in GDP.

Saga's regular quarterly surveys since 2010 show that the over 50s have been cutting back on a wide range of goods and services – even essentials – as they reassess their financial situation in response to the rising cost of living. Around half of older households have reported cutting back on clothes, shopping, entertainment and three quarters on hospitality and food.

The CEBR report, released to coincide with the latest Monetary Policy Committee meeting, is part of the Saga Thought Leadership series and aims to inform and stimulate debate among policymakers and commentators.

In response to the findings, Saga suggests a four-point plan to kick-start growth and boost employment more effectively than current policies and hopes that George Osborne will consider these for urgent action.

Pensions expert Dr Ros Altmann said: “The Bank of England has scored an unexpected own goal with the effect of its policies on the over 50s. This age group represents more than half of UK households and contributes nearly half of all domestic consumption but the toxic combination of rock-bottom interest rates, spiralling inflation and QE money-printing has put a big squeeze on their incomes, forcing many to make cutbacks.

“This change in spending habits has not just hit their living standards it has also sucked almost £25billion out of the economy, reduced the Treasury's tax take and may have inadvertently helped tip us into recession.”

The CEBR report also highlights the catastrophic drop in income falling gilt yields have had on pension savers and the hundreds of thousands of people buying annuities each year.

Lower gilt yields following QE mean:

* Annual income from a £100,000 annuity for a 65-year-old man has fallen nearly 20% in three years.

* The value of a £100,000 capped drawdown policy for a 65-year-old man has fallen 33% due to the combination of QE and Treasury rule changes.

“With nearly a million people due to buy annuities over the next two years, as the number of baby boomers reaching retirement peaks, current monetary policy is cutting many pensioners' incomes – permanently,” says Dr Altmann.

Dr Altmann suggests that policymakers ignore these facts at their peril and that they should be acting now to find alternative policies to stimulate economic activity.

She concludes: “We need the authorities to look at more effective ways of reinvigorating the economy. If they want to generate growth and employment, they should be considering a plan without the damaging side-effects of QE.”

Prof Douglas McWilliams, Chief Executive of CEBR and Gresham Professor of Commerce said: “While QE may have supported the UK economy during the financial crisis by preventing deflation, it is not a measure without cost. By pushing up prices, the inflationary impact of QE has placed downward pressure on real incomes which has a particularly severe effect on those with fixed incomes and this will have reduced household consumption.

“Those pensioners hit hardest are those who have had to take out an annuity in the past four years, who will be retiring on much lower incomes than they might have expected, after working hard to pay for their retirement. Also pensioners who rely on interest income will had their income reduced in the same way.

“The effects of these factors are not confined of course just to those pensioners directly affected because the impact of their spending spreads out through the economy through those who supply them with goods and services.”

As a result of its research Saga believes there are more effective policies that should be considered. It recommends:

* Temporary tax breaks for capital spending to encourage companies to bring forward investment plans currently on ice.

* Introducing meaningful incentives for house building, for example, building aspirational housing suitable for older generations downsizing, which would both help the property market and stimulate growth.

Harnessing the power of pension fund assets to bypass the banks and invest in infrastructure and lend directly to small business, with a Government underpin to mitigate some of the risk. So far, all the credit and lending schemes have relied on banks to pass on lower lending rates. However, with an impaired banking system, the usual mechanisms are not working. Facilitating more borrowing is not just about lower interest rates. Over-cautious, weakened banks have significantly increased fees and tightened lending conditions which has left many small or medium firms unable to borrow.

The Bank of England must stop buying more gilts, lavishing billions of pounds on a strategy which undermines the UK's pension system and will be painful to unwind.

Read our PDF about the impact of Quantitative Easing on the incomes of people over 50


The opinions expressed are those of the author and are not held by Saga unless specifically stated.

The material is for general information only and does not constitute investment, tax, legal, medical or other form of advice. You should not rely on this information to make (or refrain from making) any decisions. Always obtain independent, professional advice for your own particular situation.

Related

  • Pensions

    How to keep on top of your pension fund

    Holly Thomas has some useful tips to help you keep a close track on your pension pot.

    Read on

  • Cashpoint at a bank

    A look at the new banks on the high street

    There is a new mood of competition on the high street. Four new or expanded banks are trying to tempt us away from the Big Five. But how are the new banks making themselves different from traditional banks?

    Read on

  • £50 notes

    Claim your share of mis-sold PPI money

    The High Street banks and credit card providers have now set aside nearly £10 billion to pay compensation to people who were systematically mis-sold payment protection insurance on loans and credit cards. Less than half the money has been paid out. The other half is sitting there waiting for claims – perhaps from you, writes Paul Lewis.

    Read on

  • Pound coins

    How to deal with debt

    Nearly one in five people retiring this year will do so in debt, owing an average of £38,200, according to new research.

    Read on

  • Annuity

    Annuities Service

    Up to 16% more retirement income through the Saga Annuity Service provided by Legal & General.

    MORE INFO

  • Equity release

    Equity release

    A way to release tax-free cash from your home, to spend on whatever you choose.

    MORE INFO

  • Web Savings thumbnail

    Fixed rate savings account

    For simple lump sum deposits designed for those looking for an attractive fixed rate.

    MORE INFO

  • ISAs thumbnail

    ISA saver

    Unlimited easy access to your funds, with an attractive, variable interest rate of 1.40% tax free/AER including a fixed bonus of 0.90% payable for the first 18 months.

    MORE INFO

  • Platinum thumbnail

    Platinum credit card

    Low rate and 0% foreign currency fees on transactions.

    MORE INFO

Spice up your life - the health benefits of spices

Eating more spices could soon be as important as eating five portions of fruit and vegetables a day

The care debacle

Royal Commissions, White Papers, the Dilnot report...are we any nearer solving the problem of who pays when we’re old and in need of care? Probably not, says Paul Lewis.

Saga Magazine

For more fascinating stories and insightful articles, why not try Saga Magazine for just £1 for 3 issues.

Saga Platinum credit card

The ideal travel companion for the over 50s, offering great benefits whether you spend at home or abroad

Representative 11.9% APR (Variable) 

Travel Money

BUY TODAY

Order your travel money today with our safe and secure online ordering system.

0% commission on foreign currencies and free next day delivery.