QE 'panic' puts pensioners in firing line again

By Ros Altmann , Thursday 9 February 2012

Pensioners could be the big losers in the wake of the Bank of England's decision to extend Quantitative Easing by a further £50bn.
Bank piling on the agony for pensionersBank piling on the agony for pensioners
But the move looks like a panic measure from a flawed policy. The market is being distorted and pensioners are being unduly punished.

Dr Ros Altmann, Director-General of Saga, said: "The Bank of England has consistently ignored the dreadful damage that its QE policy is inflicting on older people.

"With annuity rates falling by about 25% over the last four years as a result of QE, more than a million pensioners will be permanently poorer for the rest of their lives, as they have bought an annuity at rates that have been artificially depressed by the Bank of England.

"The Bank's QE policy will have disastrous side-effects for the wellbeing of millions of people in the UK relying on annuities to fund their later life, as the more gilts the Bank of England buys, the harder it becomes for people to buy good value pensions.

"But it doesn't stop there. Company pension deficits have already ballooned to £85bn, placing ever more strain on employers.

"Unfortunately we are entering a vicious circle and the Bank has got itself into a fix. If it doesn't buy gilts then the price of gilts will tumble and that makes the deficit harder to finance. Yet if it does buy gilts, it continues to pile more pain onto pensioners and damages growth, without enough offsetting stimulus.

"It must be remembered that the aim of QE is to stimulate the economy and fight 'deflation'. But the economy is not as weak as feared. We are not facing deflation, the rate of inflation is still far too high and therefore more QE seems like a panic measure and another roll of the dice, which may not work out anyway.

"Why are we taking such massive risks? And making pensioners permanently poorer when they did nothing wrong at all? We are calling on the Bank of England to review how it operates its policy."

Ros Altmann suggests alternative measures that she believes could be more useful than the QE policy:

1. Create new money and drop pounds notes from a helicopter, so people can spend them

2. Use newly created money to underwrite small business loans to spread some of the risk that lenders take

3. Use newly created money to lend directly to small businesses who are starved of credit and want to expand

4. Set up a new lending institution to lend to growing companies

5. Use newly created money to fund infrastructure projects alongside pension funds

Related

  • Ros Altmann

    Permanent damage to pensions due to QE policy

    As the Bank of England decides whether to extend its policy of Quantitative Easing, Saga Director-General Ros Altmann warns that this will be yet another devastating blow for pensioners.

    Read on

  • Part of PPI compensation is taxable

    Short-changed on future pension income

    Around half a million people retiring each year are being short-changed by up to £1billion from their total future pension income, because overwhelming obstacles stop them getting the best deal, says a new study.

    Read on

  • £50 notes

    ISAs, in a nutshell

    Normally when you save money in a deposit account, any interest you receive has at least 20% deducted from it in the form of tax. However, a Cash ISA (Individual Savings Account) is a special type of account where the interest is paid tax-free.

    Read on

  • Part of PPI compensation is taxable

    How to deal with debt

    Nearly one in five people retiring this year will do so in debt, owing an average of £38,200, according to new research.

    Read on

  • Soaring inflation

    Inflation hits buying power of older people

    Older people are the worst hit victims of soaring inflation. Pensioners have been particularly hard hit as they have seen inflation increase by over 20 per cent since the start of the credit crunch.

    Read on

  • Annuity

    Annuity service

    Up to 16% more retirement income through the Saga Annuity Service provided by Legal & General.

    MORE INFO

  • ISAs thumbnail

    3 Year Fixed rate ISA

    Available now for cash ISA deposits for the 2011/12 tax year.

    MORE INFO

  • Web Savings thumbnail

    Internet Saver

    An attractive variable interest rate of 2.40% gross/AER including a fixed first year bonus of 1.90%.

    MORE INFO

  • ISAs thumbnail

    ISA saver

    Unlimited easy access to your funds, with an attractive, variable interest rate of 2.70% tax free/AER including a fixed bonus of 1.10% payable for the first 18 months.

    MORE INFO

  • Equity release

    Equity release

    A way to release tax-free cash from your home, to spend on whatever you choose.

    MORE INFO

  • Platinum thumbnail

    Platinum credit card

    Low rate and 0% foreign currency fees on transactions.

    MORE INFO


  • David Eppel

    Posted: Saturday 18 February 2012

    the underperforming fund managers must take some blame-along with regulators who allowed them to make spurious claims. QE is of course a clueless desperate act that rewards the villains whilst allowing the crime to continue. Governments are helpless against banks,or have vested interest. Dr.Altman you are spot on- I suggested a moratorium on council tax-that way the 'squeezed middle' would be the winners. We also need to wrest power from the banks,cap immigration and benefits.

  • Simon Spooner

    Posted: Thursday 9 February 2012

    I worked for a major company in the pensions industry in the 1970's It was known by actuaries that UK private pensions would fail about 2005. They did. All governenments have ignored the situation. Now we have the ongoing problem that poor pensioners will not pay much tax, purchase very few goods and require more state support. This will lead to lasting stress to the economy - a fact not mentioned by anyone including yourself. UK plc needs to design a thriving pensioners' sector. Quickly.

COMMENTS

Type your comment here


 characters remaining.

3 Year Fixed rate ISA

  • Earn 3.70% tax free / AER
  • A tax free way to save
  • Security of a fixed return over one year
  • Deposit from just £1 up to £5,640 for the 2012/2013 tax year

Saga Platinum credit card

The ideal travel companion for the over 50s, offering great benefits whether you spend at home or abroad

Representative 11.9% APR (Variable) 

Saga money e-newsletter

Sign up for our fortnightly money newsletter for the latest money saving tips and news.