October 3, 2011: So I'm not the only mug

By Judith Wills , Friday 30 September 2011

Alphabet J Judith Wills was a leading diet guru in the Eighties. Then, at 61, following an injury she “went to pot” and hit 12 stone. She vowed to spend 2011 getting back to shape and Saga is following her diet and exercise plan with her blogs, videos and forum posts. This is the latest instalment, for more search ' Judith Wills' in the search box


Crown Prince supper Crown Prince supper

One in five of us start a diet every month, apparently. That means one in five of us stop a diet every month too, or so it says in the Daily Mail.

Do we really? It sounds like complete madness. Start a diet March 1st. Stick to it for a week or so. Pack it in. Pig out. Start another diet April 1st.

Don't we know better than this by now? Surely everyone must have read countless times that the only way to lose weight is to choose a way of eating you enjoy and is healthy and that will get the weight off slowly/steadily over time. You carry on until you're at a comfortable weight, then you simply carry on – maybe upping portion sizes a little – so that you don't put it all back on again. Simple.

And yet I know that not many of us do follow that simple way. We still want the quick fix. We still want to miracle diet. We still want to believe what the guru tells us and not what our own common sense tells us.

Will we ever learn? I hope so. Yes, I've tried various mad or not very nice diets during this Challenge. I did it to find out whether I had been too harsh in the past on fads and crashes and pseudo-science that isn't science at all. And I found out that no, I hadn't been too harsh – most of it is not only rubbish that doesn't work, but unpalatable rubbish too.

And in the past few weeks there's been yet more research that yo-yo dieting is bad for us – it's better to stay a bit overweight than keep losing then gaining.

So if you're thinking of trying yet another diet this month, please stop – don't be like the March hare or the April fool this October.

If you're not going to stick to it, don't start it – you'll be much happier for the next four weeks, I can assure you.

Ate last night: A fairly light supper of roast Crown Prince pumpkin chunks with feta cheese, rocket, pine nuts and a lemon dressing (see photo). Every year we grow squash and pumpkin and the Crown Prince is one of the best. It's even tastier than butternut squash. You can use pumpkin or sunflower seeds if the current extortionate price of pine nuts puts you off buying them.

Recipe – serves 2 generously

  • 500g Crown Prince pumpkin
  • 2 tbsp olive oil
  • Juice of half a lemon
  • ½ tsp caster sugar
  • ½ tsp French mustard
  • Salt and black pepper
  • 100g feta cheese
  • Handful rocket leaves
  • 1½ tbsp toasted pine nuts

1. Peel the pumpkin and cut into chunks. Put in roasting tin, coat with 1 tbsp olive oil and seasoning, and roast at 190C for 45 minutes, turning halfway through. Meanwhile shake together the remaining olive oil with the lemon juice, sugar, mustard and seasoning.

2. When the pumpkin is soft and golden, stir the dressing gently in and divide between two plates. Top with the crumbled cheese, rocket leaves and pine nuts to serve.

Click here to read Judith's Diet Challenge blog archive.

Related

  • Judith Wills

    September 30, 2011: Weighing it all up so far

    Judith Wills was a leading diet guru in the Eighties. Then, at 61, following an injury she “went to pot” and hit 12 stone. She vowed to spend 2011 getting back to shape and Saga is following her diet and exercise plan with her blogs, videos and forum posts. This is the latest instalment, for more search 'Judith Wills' in the search box

    Read on

  • Judith Wills

    September 28, 2011: Can food ever be boring?

    Judith Wills was a leading diet guru in the Eighties. Then, at 61, following an injury she “went to pot” and hit 12 stone. She vowed to spend 2011 getting back to shape and Saga is following her diet and exercise plan with her blogs, videos and forum posts. This is the latest instalment, for more search 'Judith Wills' in the search box

    Read on

  • Judith Wills

    September 26, 2011: Sleep walking

    If you happen to have been reading this blog since the start, or read about my diet challenge in the early days in Saga Magazine, you may remember that I have often moaned about insomnia

    Read on

  • Judith Wills

    September 23, 2011: The Assault on the Bluff – shock! Horror!

    OK it's only a little hill really, in comparative terms, but it's a mountain to me. Hay Bluff, that is. My friend Glenys and I finally walked up it yesterday. Well, I say walked up it but in fact I puffed and panted and stopped and started and moaned and groaned my way up it. Walking just isn't the word

    Read on

  • Health thumbnail

    Health insurance

    A comprehensive range of competitively priced HealthPlans. 3 months free when you pay by monthly Direct Debit.

    MORE DETAILS

  • HCP thumbnail

    Health Cash Plan

    You can claim up to 75% of your common everyday healthcare expenses including dental and optical treatments.

    MORE DETAILS

  • Related Products Health

    International Health Insurance

    If you are living abroad it is vital to protect your health and have the right healthcare cover.

    MORE DETAILS


  • Jesse Walker

    Posted: Tuesday 1 May 2012

    Its really very good information about weight loss. Its very helpful to decrease our extra fat.Thanks for sharing and keep it up.

  • Julie Dorrell

    Posted: Friday 30 December 2011

    Well Done Judith, you really seem to have done what you set out to do. What I am most impressed and curious about is what were the specific things you did, do you think, that reduced your waistline? I am just over 10 stone, 5ft 9" tall very late 60s but what fat I do have is all around my waist and I should dearly like to get rid of it or move it to my bottom, which is uncomfortably thin to sit on! Any thoughts, thanks Julie D

COMMENTS

Type your comment here


 characters remaining.

Champneys spa breaks

3 nights for 2 or 20% discount

Exclusive Saga offer - treat yourself to rest, relaxation and rejuvenation with a break at a Champneys resort.

Saga health e-newsletter

Keep up to date with the latest health news by signing up to our fortnightly health e-newsletter.

Health Insurance

Over 50s get 3 months free when you pay by monthly Direct Debit

  • Prompt access to private medical treatment
  • A great choice of HealthPlans
  • Easy to take out cover.

Saga Magazine

Claim your free issue today and find out why we're the UK's bestselling monthly magazine.