David Gritten on film: March 16, 2012

By David Gritten, Friday 16 March 2012

David Gritten, Saga Magazine's film expert, reviews In Darkness, Jane Eyre and Resistance

A scene from In Darkness
In cinemas

In Darkness

A suspenseful, satisfying account of human survival against the odds, In Darkness tells the story of a group of Polish Jews in the city of Lvov, which was occupied by the Nazis in 1943. Rather than stay around and witness the liquidation of their ghetto, and their probable deportation to death camps, this group (which included children) went underground – literally – and hid in the city’s sewers for 14 long months (click the image on the right to watch the trailer).

Yet the most interesting, complex character in this real-life story isn’t one of these survivors, but a Polish sewer worker named Leopold Socha. He dislikes and distrusts Jews and only agrees to hide and shelter them underground for money. Socha knows the sewer system inside out; a petty thief, he stashes his loot down there. But as the months go by, he develops a moral compass and some feelings for the Jews, buying them food with his own money, even though it puts his own life at risk.

The accomplished veteran Polish director Agnieszka Holland has opted to tell a human-scale story that stands as a microcosm of the Holocaust. In dramatic terms, the amoral Socha is a figure similar to Oskar Schindler – a man defying his worst instincts to behave with decency and compassion. Film buffs may also recall Andrzej Wajda’s brilliant Kanal (1957), which dealt with Polish partisans in the sewers.

In Darkness has an uplifting ending, and, given that the group of survivors is small and tight-knit, an epic quality. Highly recommended. With sub-titles, it’s in the languages various characters would have spoken: Polish, German, Yiddish and Ukrainian.


Jane Eyre

In hindsight, last year’s adaptation of Charlotte Bronte’s beloved classic Jane Eyre was among the best of 22 attempts to date to re-work it for film or TV. Against all odds, Japanese-American director Cary Fukunaga makes the story feel fresh, urgent and original.

He has concentrated heavily on Jane’s tough orphan childhood; the stark beauty of the story’s moorland setting becomes a visual equivalent to her steely-minded character.

Casting is also a crucial component here, and Michael Fassbender, who has become a major movie star since he shot this piece, is a handsome, flawed, even neurotic Mr Rochester. Australian actress Mia Wasihowska is every bit his match as a modern Jane, brave, devoted and passionate. Judi Dench is a welcome presence as Mrs Fairfax the housekeeper; it all adds up to an impressive package. (Available now).


Based on Owen Sheers’ novel, this is effectively an alternative history. It’s set in a remote Welsh valley in 1944: the D-Day landings have failed and Germany has invaded Britain. One morning the woman of the valley wake up to find their husbands have disappeared; in their absence, they establish a wary truce with a German patrol.

It’s paced rather slowly, and while it’s not lacking in suspense, the thought occurs that it would play better on television. The ever-reliable Andrea Riseborough acquits herself well as one of the wives. (Available March 19).

David Gritten

David GrittenDavid Gritten has been Saga Magazine’s film critic for eight years. He also regularly writes about and reviews films for the Daily Telegraph. He has lived and worked in London and Los Angeles,  and has visited film sets all over the world. He edited Halliwell’s film guide for two years (2008-09). He feels privileged to have met and interviewed his four major film heroes: Fred Astaire, Billy Wilder, Martin Scorsese and Pedro Almodóvar.

Read David Gritten every month in the the Out There section of Saga Magazine - full of unmissable events, book reviews, art, music, special offers and a whole lot more. Find out why we're the UK's best-selling magazine: Subscribe here now.


  • Film clapperboard

    David Gritten on film: March 9, 2012

    David Gritten, Saga Magazine's film expert, reviews Bel Ami, Trishna, The Help and My Week with Marilyn

    Read on

  • Film clapperboard

    Film blog: March 2, 2012

    David Gritten, Saga Magazine's film expert, on the latest cinema and dvd releases.

    Read on

  • One of the sets on display

    The Making of Harry Potter

    The Making of Harry Potter promises to become one of the UK’s leading tourist attractions. Neil Davey gets a sneak peek – alongside Professor Flitwick, Tonks and Draco Malfoy. Oh, alright then, actors Warwick Davis, Natalia Tena and Tom Felton

    Read on

  • The Best Exotic Marigold Hotel

    Exclusive: Dame Judi Dench talks about her new film The Best Exotic Marigold Hotel

    The Best Exotic Marigold Hotel is a film about a retirement home in Rajasthan – for UK pensioners. The idea really struck a chord with the cast, by necessity all of a certain age. Here they share their thoughts in our exclusive behind-the-scenes interviews

    Read on

  • A half-hour with Hancock

    Sheila Hancock seems at the top of her game. But, despite her trademark no-nonsense style, she still admits to loneliness, almost 10 years after the death of her husband John Thaw

    Read on

  • War Horse still

    Steven Spielberg, Richard Curtis and Emily Watson talk to Saga

    From acclaimed novel to celebrated stage play, the evolution of War Horse has proved the power of a good story. Michael Morpurgo's moving tale is now a major film, with the involvement of some quite remarkable names

    Read on

  • Singin' in the Rain

    Encore theatre tickets

    Great deals and exclusive offers for Saga customers on West End theatre tickets, including matinee club offers, meet the cast events and 2 for 1 deals.



Type your comment here

 characters remaining.

Saga Magazine

For more fascinating stories and insightful articles, why not try Saga Magazine for just £1 for 3 issues.

Saga Magazine e-newsletter

Sign up to our free newsletter today

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter for all the latest recipes, gardening tips, prize draws, interviews and more delivered to your inbox every Friday.

Saga Magazine app

You can now read your Saga Magazine on a huge range of mobile devices - from the Kindle Fire to an iPhone or iPad.

English Heritage offer

Get £10 off English Heritage membership

Get out and about this spring with £10 off English Heritage membership. Enter code SG15W at checkout.