Is Branston still best? Pickles tried and tasted

We test the classic pickle against its supermarket rivals to find out which to bring out for your sandwiches, cheeses and meats.

Image credit: Getty Images
By Saga Magazine | Published - 24 Jun 2025
Share this page on Facebook Share this page on X Share this page on Pinterest Share this page via e-mail

1. Branston Original Pickle

Winner

360g, £2.10

This classic British favourite did not fail to impress!

The tangy sauce, with malty sweetness, was perfectly balanced and blended well with the crunchy diced veg.

  • 9/10

2. Tracklements Perfect Ploughman’s Pickle

245g, £3.75

A rather runny pickle with a pale colour that made it look homemade but not very appetising.

However, it tasted delicious. With small cubes of crunchy veg in a slightly sweet sauce, it’s mild and different.

  • 8/10

Check price

3. Aldi Bramwell's Sweet Pickle

390g, £1.25

Not for the faint-hearted, this good-value pickle contained large chunks of perfectly cooked veg in a vinegar-heavy sauce, which certainly packs a punch.

If you are fan of pickled onions, this is for you.

  • 7/10

Check price

4. Waitrose Ploughman's Pickle

310g, £2.60

A dark, richly coloured pickle, subtly sweet rather than sharp with smaller chunks of veg that were a little soft.

The overall consistency made it more suited for a sandwich rather than as a portion presented on the plate.

  • 7/10

Check price

5. Lidl Batts Sweet Pickle

390g, £1.19

A great-value pickle which, with its strong pickled onion flavour, would be an ideal complement to a cheese ploughman’s.

The tangy sauce was a rich, dark colour and contained plenty of large, crunchy vegetable chunks.

  • 7/10

6. Tesco Sandwich Pickle

295g, £1.45

Very small chunks of rather soft veg including an abundance of onion.

The sauce was gloopy and left a strong, vinegary aftertaste.

  • 5/10

Check price

7. Sweet Pickle by Sainsbury’s

295g, £1.15

This was sweeter than most with a somewhat artificial flavour.

Smooth in texture with a light taste as the fino lemon juice did not really deliver a deep citrus tang.

  • 5/10

Check price

Our reviewers are mother and daughter team Diana Redfern and Emma Gill. 

Related articles
A boiled egg with the top removed and a runny yolk, with a small piece of bread dipped in
How to cook a perfect boiled egg - From the ultimate egg to an air fryer hack
A person putting tomatoes away - but should tomatoes be stored in the fridge? | GettyLiudmila Chernetska
Don’t store these 7 foods in the fridge
Young man and his senior father going through shopping list while buying in supermarket
How to save money on your food shop – without noticing the difference
Bread, cheese and wine on a wooden board
Love food and wine?

Find out about Saga's gastronomy holidays here...

They say the way to the heart is through the stomach, and Saga’s thoughtfully crafted food and wine holidays are perfect if you like trying new flavours and exploring traditional methods of cooking.

Find out more
Clare Balding Christmas promo card
Give the gift that keeps on giving

Treat someone special to a Saga Magazine subscription – 12 inspiring issues for just £34.95. Plus, you will also enjoy three free gifts: a cotton tote bag, a bumper puzzle book and a box of Guylian Seashell chocolates.

Every issue is packed with real-life stories, exclusive celebrity interviews, insightful articles and practical tips on health, finance, travel, and more. A thoughtful gift that entertains all year round.

Subscribe

Related articles

Mature man in a kitchen, holding the lid of a pot with steam billowing up in front
The foods you should never reheat – and why the rules aren’t as strict as you think

From rice to roast chicken, there’s a lot of confusing advice about leftover food. We ask the experts to separate fact from fiction.

An older persons hands making a cup of tea
Why you should never squeeze your teabag – and other golden tea-making rules

Want to make the perfect brew? Then follow these expert tips

Young man and his senior father going through shopping list while buying in supermarket
How to save money on your food shop – without noticing the difference

We’ve found the best money-saving alternatives to some of the most popular branded products. 

potatoes and onions being stored together
The foods you must never store together
We've got the 5 common food pairs to always store apart.
Chinese peking duck wrapped in pancakes with cucumber, spring onions and hoisin sauce
How to cook Chinese food in an air fryer - with 3 easy recipes to try

We've got expert advice on how to cook up a feast in your air fryer in minutes.

A person putting tomatoes away - but should tomatoes be stored in the fridge? | GettyLiudmila Chernetska
Don’t store these 7 foods in the fridge

These foods will lose flavour and freshness if you store them in the fridge.

A man wearing an apron pours white wine from a glass into a pan of food, with various vegetables on the worktop
Diana Henry's tips for cooking with alcohol
If you've got leftover sherry, vermouth or limoncello, the food writer shares her advice on how to use alcohol in your cooking.
Close-up of a barista pouring frothed milk into a coffee mug in front of a large coffee machine
The secrets of cafe-quality coffee (and it’s not just about the machine)
We quizzed the experts on why a barista brew always tastes so good – and got some insider tips on how to recreate it at home.
Hand swirling a glass of red wine on a blurred background of a wine cellar
The best low alcohol wines offering great taste without the headache
Want to take a break from booze? From low-alcohol Tempranillo to 0% aperitifs, our expert has the best on offer.
Celebrating
years of Saga