Is Branston still best? Pickles tried and tasted

We test the classic pickle against its supermarket rivals to find out which to bring out for your sandwiches, cheeses and meats.

pickle in a bowl with a spoon next to a pork pie
Image credit: Getty Images
By Saga Magazine | Published - 24 Jun 2025
Social Facebook Social Twitter Social Pinterest Email

1. Branston Original Pickle

Winner

360g, £2.10

This classic British favourite did not fail to impress!

The tangy sauce, with malty sweetness, was perfectly balanced and blended well with the crunchy diced veg.

  • 9/10

2. Tracklements Perfect Ploughman’s Pickle

245g, £3.75

A rather runny pickle with a pale colour that made it look homemade but not very appetising.

However, it tasted delicious. With small cubes of crunchy veg in a slightly sweet sauce, it’s mild and different.

  • 8/10

Check price

3. Aldi Bramwell's Sweet Pickle

390g, £1.25

Not for the faint-hearted, this good-value pickle contained large chunks of perfectly cooked veg in a vinegar-heavy sauce, which certainly packs a punch.

If you are fan of pickled onions, this is for you.

  • 7/10

Check price

4. Waitrose Ploughman's Pickle

310g, £2.60

A dark, richly coloured pickle, subtly sweet rather than sharp with smaller chunks of veg that were a little soft.

The overall consistency made it more suited for a sandwich rather than as a portion presented on the plate.

  • 7/10

Check price

5. Lidl Batts Sweet Pickle

390g, £1.19

A great-value pickle which, with its strong pickled onion flavour, would be an ideal complement to a cheese ploughman’s.

The tangy sauce was a rich, dark colour and contained plenty of large, crunchy vegetable chunks.

  • 7/10

6. Tesco Sandwich Pickle

295g, £1.45

Very small chunks of rather soft veg including an abundance of onion.

The sauce was gloopy and left a strong, vinegary aftertaste.

  • 5/10

Check price

7. Sweet Pickle by Sainsbury’s

295g, £1.15

This was sweeter than most with a somewhat artificial flavour.

Smooth in texture with a light taste as the fino lemon juice did not really deliver a deep citrus tang.

  • 5/10

Check price

Our reviewers are mother and daughter team Diana Redfern and Emma Gill. 

Related articles
Carrot cake on a plate about to be eaten
The best Carrot cake to buy: tried and tasted
a bowl containing black limes on a white tablecloth
Love Middle Eastern food? Why you should be cooking with black limes
A selection of wines mentioned in the below article.
The best wine matches for your favourite films
Bread, cheese and wine on a wooden board
Love food and wine?

Find out about Saga's gastronomy holidays here...

They say the way to the heart is through the stomach, and Saga’s thoughtfully crafted food and wine holidays are perfect if you like trying new flavours and exploring traditional methods of cooking.

Find out more
A print magazine, a puzzle book and a parker jotter pen in front of a Christmas cracker
Christmas has come early!

Subscribe now to get our Christmas issue and start preparing for the festive season. Enjoy seasonal recipes from Rick Stein, Christmas interiors and decoration guides, gift ideas and more.

Treat yourself to 12 issues for just £29.95 plus, enjoy two free gifts: a classic Parker Jotter Pen in a festive cracker and a bumper puzzle book.

 

Subscribe

Related articles

Mary Berry's classic fruit scones
Mary Berry's fruit scones
Mary Berry's recipe for fruit scones, plus her tips for making the best scones.
A large number of pumpkins
Autumnal pumpkin recipes for your air fryer

Never airfried pumpkin before? Our guide to making tasty pumpkin dishes in an air fryer shows you how.

A boiled egg with the top removed and a runny yolk, with a small piece of bread dipped in
How to cook a perfect boiled egg - From the ultimate egg to an air fryer hack

The best ways to boil an egg, which may surprise you, and the egg-boiling mistakes to avoid.

a plate of chicken kiev with risotto on a wooden table
Aldo Zilli's healthy chicken Kiev with saffron rice

Italian chef, Aldo Zilli's heart-healthy chicken kiev recipe that tastes incredible

Mary Berry's potato, leek and cheese pie
Mary Berry’s potato, leek and cheese pie
A creamy potato, cheese and leek pie filling in flaky pastry from Mary Berry.
Prawns on a bed of beans in a skillet
James Martin: The Spain attraction

Celebrity chef James Martin shares his recipes for Valencian Beans and Prawns and Creme Caramel with Spiced Seville Oranges.

Potatoes cooked in air fryers
Air fryer potatoes: Expert tips for making the tastiest potatoes
Roast, baked and even mash – yes, the air fryer is a master of the potato game. Here’s how to make perfect air fryer potatoes every time.
A delicious chicken kyiv | Getty Images
The best chicken Kyiv we've tried and tasted
Chicken Kiev has been popular for more than a century, but which supermarket Kyiv is best?
Close-up of a barista pouring frothed milk into a coffee mug in front of a large coffee machine
The secrets of cafe-quality coffee (and it’s not just about the machine)
We quizzed the experts on why a barista brew always tastes so good – and got some insider tips on how to recreate it at home.