Research suggests fitness trackers may discourage some users. Here’s why, and what a sports psychologist says you can do about it.
Hands up if you’ve bought a fitness tracker thinking this was the thing that was finally going to get you moving and motivated… only to find that the reality hasn’t quite lived up to the intention.
You’re not alone. In fact, a 2023 study by Warwick Business School and the National University of Singapore found that certain features on fitness trackers may actually discourage users from exercising.
Many wearable devices, including Fitbits and Apple Watches, incorporate a social element into their apps, allowing users to compare their activity with others, and compete to see who is most active. While for some this can be highly motivating, for others, this feature actually discouraged them from exercising.
The researchers looked at people who were taking part in competitions on a popular fitness app.
They looked at what feedback individual users were getting about their performance and how they were doing against other people, and compared this with the amount of exercise each person then did.
They divided participants in the study into one of three categories – active, moderately active, or inactive.
They found that if you’re already an active or moderately active person, then seeing your performance improve against your peers is likely to have a motivational effect and increase the amount of activity you do overall.
But for those of us who are less active, it’s a rather different story. The picture is not a straightforward one, however. For those classed as inactive, there seems to be a law of diminishing returns.
According to the research, published in the Journal of the Association for Information Systems, such users “were more likely to increase the distance they walked or ran after being shown how their performance had progressed compared to their peers”.
So far so good: comparing your activity levels to someone else’s, and seeing how you’ve improved, can be motivating.
But the researchers also noted that a decline in performance can be demotivating, and that it’s more demotivating for new exercisers than those who are more experienced.
According to the lead author of the study, Yang Yang, Assistant Professor of Information Systems at Warwick Business School:
“Wearable tech and mobile apps that adopt a competitive, game-like approach are used increasingly to nudge people towards healthier behaviour.
“But our findings indicate that in some circumstances, they can have the opposite effect.”
The research also found that inactive users were less likely to be motivated by the competitive aspect of these devices:
“Inactive exercisers with a lower level of exercise activity may feel less confident in their ability to outperform opponents... which results in a lower extent of exercise behaviour increase.”
We asked clinical sports psychologist Dr Victor Thompson for his thoughts. He explains:
“Few people respond well to negative feedback. This looks to be the same in this research – when users learn that they are performing less well than peers, they are discouraged.
“Their mind might say: ‘It’s better not to bother.’ Then the users can always say to themselves: ‘Well, I didn’t try, so a low ranking isn’t reflective of my level.’ Then there is less to accept mentally.
“Alternatively, less active users may have less experience of being active for internal reasons – for example, what it gives the user (a buzz, sense of competence, fitness…) – rather than external reasons, such as ‘How do I compare to others?’ or ‘How will others see me?’”
The researchers suggest that it is keen exercisers who are most motivated by the thought of competing with others.
In comparison, people who don’t exercise much “may not be able to perceive the same level of enjoyment and arousal as active exercisers” from the sense of being in competition.
In essence, if someone feels less confident in their ability, they may take less enjoyment from competing with others.
They also found that moderate exercisers were not motivated to exercise by “intense rivalry”, perhaps because it puts them under “excessive pressure”.
Fitness trackers are designed to encourage and support people in reaching their fitness goals. But if they risk being counterproductive for some, is there anything that can be done to mitigate that? Dr Thompson offers the following top tips:
While for some people, seeing how they are doing in comparison to others can give them something to aim for, and a sense of achievement when they surpass someone. But for others it can potentially have a demotivating effect.
If you notice you’re not reacting positively to these aspects of wearing a fitness tracker, then bear in mind the advice from Dr Thomas: remember that there are numerous health benefits to being active.
Remind yourself that day-to-day fluctuations are normal, and what matters is your progress over time.
Focus on yourself, rather than comparing yourself to people who are at a different stage in their fitness journey.
And if it’s going to help, there’s nothing wrong from stepping away from the competition to focus on what’s going to work best for you.
NHS England wants everyone to be using its app within three years - we look at the situation UK-wide and what to do if you haven't got a smart phone.
When it comes to tracking your body composition, are smart scales accurate enough to be useful?
The pros, the cons, with expert advice on whether to take your running indoors or out.
We are here to help you decide which wearable is right for you, a sleek fitness tracker or feature-packed smartwatch
Cleaning with an electric toothbrush is much easier, especially if you have mobility problems in your hands.
Your questions answered about what really is a good 5k time.
